The CLG release details some of the findings of research by Ipsos MORI into the trials of HIPs carried out between November 2006 and April 2007, prior to their general introduction later in 2007. At the time the trials were heavily criticized as the publicity for, and cost of, the packs to sellers, was subsidized by CLG to the tune of some £4 million pounds. None of the results of the trials were made public before the imposition of HIPs on the entire residential property market.
Head of SPLINTA, Nick Salmon, said today that the figures quoted in the CLG press release are being used to 'spin' the supposed benefits of HIPs and paint a thoroughly misleading picture of the reality of the packs in today's market.
"CLG say 72% of sellers were satisfied with HIPs in the trial. Of course they were, as the packs costs them nothing. I'm surprised it wasn't 100%. Apparently 79% agreed that trial packs contained 'everything expected'. That is a meaningless statement as we have no idea what those sellers were expecting. 81% understood the documents including the Energy Performance Certificate. An EPC graph could be understood by a child but I don't believe that many people would understand easements, covenants and wayleaves without professional guidance, so I question just which documents these sellers were supposedly understanding."
Salmon went on to highlight a glaring omission from the CLG release.
"I find it extremely telling that this release is absolutely silent on the matter of whether or not HIPs are actually having a beneficial impact on transactions times and fall through rates in property sales - which was the original goal before saving the plant took priority. In case they have not got that far in their analysis of the trial, let me tell the Minister what is happening in the real world today. HIPs are doing absolutely nothing to hold sales together, nor are they cutting the time between acceptance of offer and exchange of contracts. Buyers don't want to see them, and sellers have no interest in them. If she does not believe me, I challenge her to spend a few days actually in estate agents' offices to see the reality for herself"
SPLINTA has campaigned against the Home Information Pack since 2001 and now has an online petition running on the Number 10 Downing Street website to try and head off a further change to the HIP legislation later this year. Nick Salmon thinks the Government has been taken aback by the massive public response to the petition and sees moves afoot to tarnish estate agents so that the aim of the petition fails.
"HIPs are unloved by the property industry and unwanted by the public. They will become even more unpopular in June when the Government plans to end the ability of a seller to go on the market immediately they want to. Our petition against the ending of this 'first day marketing' concession is in the Top 20 by size of over 7,700 such petitions on the Number Ten Downing Street website. The implication of the CLG press release is that estate agents are in some way responsible for the fact that buyers don't see a HIP. They don't see it because they are not interested in seeing it and the suggestion is a blatant attempt by CLG to create a reason for ending first day marketing. If it wasn't potentially so serious, it would be laughable"
ENDS
Further information and comment: Nick Salmon 07831 805455
Notes to Editors.
1. Currently the marketing of a property can begin as soon as the HIP is ordered but the Government intends to end this concession on 31st May 2008 and will require that the pack is physically complete before marketing commences. Campaigners argue that because HIPs take days to produce there will be delays for sellers wanting to sell quickly and the ending of the concession to begin marketing on the chosen first day is an infringement of the personal liberty to sell a property at will. The petition (http://petitions.pm.gov.uk/homeselling) has already attracted almost 9,000 signatures.
2. The SPLINTA (SELLERS PACK LAW IS NOT THE ANSWER) campaign is supported by over 1,900 firms of estate agents, surveyors and solicitor/conveyancers with some 4,000 offices in England and Wales. For more information please visit http://www.splintacampaign.co.uk
3. The CLG press release is here: http://www.communities.gov.uk/news/corporate/713987
SPLINTA
P.O. Box 398
Stevenage
SG1 9DR